Skip to main content
Pastore's Pizza logo top - HomepagePastore's Pizza logo scroll - Homepage
  • (585)-768-4500
  • Menu
  • *
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Order Online
  • Facebook page
  • Google page
  • Order Online
Pastore's Pizza logo top - HomepagePastore's Pizza logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • *
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Order Online

Our Menu

  • Menu
  • Specials

Hearth-Baked Pizza

Pizza toppings (Small 10'' $1.25, Medium 14'' $1.75, Large 16'' $2.25, Half Sheets $2.25, Extra Large 20'' $2.75, Party $2.99):
Pepperoni, Spicy Cup ‘n’ Char Pepperoni, Mushroom, Sausage, Black Olives, Green Olives, Onion, Hot Peppers, Sweet

We offer a sweet pizza sauce upon request!

Cheese
$3.29/slice
$11.49/small 10'' (4 slices)
$15.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$19.49/large 16'' (16 slices)
$19.49/half sheets
$22.99/extra large (16 slices)
$29.99/party (32 slices)
White Pizza
$3.29/slice
$11.49/small 10'' (4 slices)
$15.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$19.49/half sheets
$19.49/large 16'' (16 slices)
$22.99/extra large (16 slices)
$29.99/party (32 slices)

With mozzarella.

Chicago Deep Dish

Try our new Chicago Deep Dish, which is made by placing mozzarella cheese directly on the dough, then additional toppings are added. We then top the pizza with your choice of regular or sweet pizza sauce.

Each additional topping: Small 10'' $1.25 | Medium 14'' $1.75 | Large 16'' $2.25

Cheese
$11.49/small 10''
$15.99/medium 14''
$19.49/large 16''

Pan Pizza

Each additional topping: Small 10'' $1.25 | Medium 14'' $1.75 | Large 16'' $2.25

Deep Dish Pan Pizza
$11.49/small 10”
$15.99/medium 14''
$19.49/large 16”

With cheese.

Gluten - Free Pizza

Our kitchen is not gluten-free.

Each additional topping +$1.25

Gluten-Free Crust
$11.99/small 10''

With cheese.

Cauliflower Crust
$11.99/small 10''

With cheese.

Specialty Pizzas

Each additional topping: Small 10'' $1.25 | Medium 14'' $1.75 | Large 16'' $2.25 | X-Large 20'' $2.75 | Party $2.99

Loaded Fry Pie
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

Ranch dressing, French fries & bacon bits smothered in mozzarella and cheddar cheese.

Cheeseburger Pizza
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

Ketchup & mustard base, chopped Angus burger, smothered with mozzarella & cheddar cheese, choice of lettuce, tomato, onion.

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

White sauce smothered with mushroom, onion, sweet peppers, steak, mozzarella, cheddar and provolone cheese.

Dill Pickle Pizza
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

Garlic sauce smothered in mozzarella with dill pickle chips and spices.

Chicken Parm Pizza
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

Homemade pasta sauce & chicken smothered with mozzarella.

Eggplant Parm Pizza
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

Homemade pasta sauce & eggplant smothered with mozzarella.

Greek Pizza
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

White sauce smothered with sliced tomato, spinach, mozzarella & feta cheese.

Taco Pizza
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

Seasoned ground beef smothered in cheddar and mozzarella cheese, lettuce & tomato.

Chicken Wing Pizza
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

Chicken smothered in mozzarella cheese with your choice of hot, medium, mild, BBQ, sweet & sour, toxic hot, spicy BBQ or cajun sauce.

Breakfast Pizza
$14.99/small 10'' (4 slices)
$21.99/medium 14'' (8 slices)
$26.99/large 16'' (16 slices)
$30.99/x-large 20'' (16 slices)
$38.99/party (32 slices)

Scrambled eggs, bacon and sausage smothered in mozzarella and cheddar.

Chicken Wings

Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ | Mild | Medium | Hot | BBQ | Sweet & Sour | Cajun | Toxic Hot | Spicy BBQ | Honey Mustard | Garlic | Raspberry | Cattlemen’s Gold Sauce

Grilled Wings

Boneless or buffalo wings
Tossed in your favorite sauce, then barbecued
on the Charbroiler! (Additional charge applies)

Buffalo Wings

Single (12 Pcs.) $15.99 | Double (24 Pcs.) $28.99 | Bucket (50 Pcs.) $51.99
Served with your choice of sauce, celery & blue cheese
Extra Blue Cheese $0.89

Boneless Wings

Single (12 Pcs.) $15.99 | Double (24 Pcs.) $28.99 | Bucket (50 Pcs.) $51.99
Served with your choice of sauce, celery & blue cheese
Extra Blue Cheese $0.89

Breaded Chicken Wings

Single (12 Pcs.) $17.99 | Double (24 Pcs.) $32.89 | Bucket (50 Pcs.) $56.99
Served with celery & blue cheese
Extra Blue Cheese $0.89

Raspberry Wings

Single (12 Pcs.) $15.99 | Double (24 Pcs.) $28.99 | Bucket (50 Pcs.) $51.99
Served with celery & blue cheese
Extra Blue Cheese $0.89

Chicken Fingers

Jumbo Chicken Fingers (1lb.)
$13.99

With French fries.

Half-Order Jumbo Chicken Fingers
$8.99

With fries.

Calzones

Try our calzones with mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese or create your own!

Calzones
$11.49

Extra topping +$1.00

Cold Subs

All subs include choice of: lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & mayonnaise, sweet & hot peppers.
Cheese choice: Mozzarella, Provolone, Swiss, American & Hot Pepper.

Veggie

Lettuce, tomatoes, onion, black & green olives, hot & sweet peppers & cheese, mayo, oil
Small $8.99 | Large $11.99

Turkey

Small $9.99 | Large $13.49

Ham

Small $9.99 | Large $13.49

Ham & Turkey

Small $9.99 | Large $13.49

Capicola

Small $9.99 | Large $13.49

Salami

Small $9.99 | Large $13.49

Italian Assorted

Small $9.99 | Large $13.49

BLT

Small $9.99 | Large $13.49

Tuna

Small $9.99 | Large $13.49

Assorted Cheese

Small $9.99 | Large $13.49

Turkey Club

Turkey, bacon & cheese
Small $11.49 | Large $14.49

Hot Subs

BBQ Rib

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Eggplant Parmesan

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Steak “Bomber”

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Pizza

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Sausage

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Meatball

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Chicken Finger

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Chicken Club

Chicken breast & bacon
Small $11.99 | Large $15.49

Chicken Parmesan

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Veal Parmesan

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Cheeseburger

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Bacon Cheeseburger

Small $11.99 | Large $15.49

Royale

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Sausage Parmesan

Small $10.99 | Large $14.49

Specialty Subs

The Chicken Bomber

Tender chicken topped with your choice of: lettuce, tomato, mushrooms, onions, sweet peppers & cheese
Small $12.49 | Large $15.49

A1 “F” (Ficarella’s) Bomber

Steak, bacon, onion rings, steak sauce, & mozzarella cheese
Small $12.49 | Large $15.49

Mexican “Bomber”

Taco seasoned ground beef on top of burger patties w/lettuce, tomato, onion,
hot peppers, salsa & melted cheese
Small $12.49 | Large $15.49

Southwest Steak “Bomber”

Shaved steak & hickory BBQ sauce topped w/melted mozzarella & loaded w/battered onion rings on a French bread roll
Small $12.49 | Large $15.49

Santa Fe Spicy Chicken “Bomber”

Spicy chicken patties topped w/salsa & melted pepper jack cheese on a French bread roll
Small $12.49 | Large $15.49

The Stinger

Steak, sliced chicken fingers, wing sauce and mozzarella cheese
Small $12.49 | Large $15.49

Fat Wraps

All wraps include choice of garlic, spinach, sun-dried tomato or plain flour tortilla shell. Lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, black & green olives, oil, mayo, provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, American or hot pepper cheese.

Add bacon or blue cheese for $0.50

Cheeseburger
$9.99
Chicken Finger
$9.99
Taco
$9.99
Steak & Cheese
$9.99
Veggie
$9.99
Tuna
$9.99
Turkey
$9.99
Ham
$9.99
Italian Assorted
$9.99
BLT
$9.99
Capicola
$9.99
Salami
$9.99

Salads

Grilled Chicken Salad
$11.99

Fresh chicken strips, lettuce, cheddar cheese, tomato, onion & choice of dressing.

Chicken Finger Salad
$11.99

Chicken fingers in your favorite sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheddar, choice of dressing.

Taco Salad
$11.99

Iceberg lettuce topped w/seasoned ground beef and nacho chips.

Antipasto Salad
$11.99

Small antipasto salad $8.99
Side salad $4.99

Chicken Finger Ranch Salad
$11.99

Romaine lettuce, onions, tomato, cheddar cheese topped w/chicken fingers & served w/ranch dressing.

Greek Chicken Salad
$11.99

Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, feta cheese, black olives, diced tomato.

Greek Pizza Salad
$11.99

Small pizza shell smothered in mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato and feta cheese.

Dinner Salad
$8.49
Party Antipasto Salad
$64.95

Italian meats, cheeses and fresh vegetables on top of iceberg lettuce. Serves 20.

Pasta Dinners

Featuring homemade spaghetti sauce.
All dinners include bread and butter and side salad.

Spaghetti w/Meatballs
$13.99
Ziti w/Meatballs
$13.99
Ravioli w/Meatballs
$14.99
Stuffed Rigatoni w/Meatballs
$14.99
Eggplant Parmesan
$14.99
Chicken Parmesan
$15.99
Veal Parm Dinner
$15.99
Side of Meatballs
$4.95
Side of Sausage
$4.95
Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
$5.99
Breadsticks (7)
$5.99

Served with pasta sauce.

Fish Fries

Includes cole slaw, French fries and bread.

Beer Battered Haddock
$14.99/+ tax

Munchies

Deep Fried Ravioli
$7.99

12 breaded ravioli served with a side of marinara sauce.

Mini Tacos
$5.99
Mozzarella Sticks (8 pieces)
$8.49
Pizza Fingers (5 pieces)
$8.99
Hodge Podge
$11.49

Breaded veggies, cauliflower, zucchini and mushrooms, 2 chicken wings.

Poppers
$7.99
French Fries
$5.25
Potato Wedges
$5.25
Loaded Fries
$8.99

Cheddar, mozzarella & bacon.

Munchie Mix
$11.99

Mozzarella stix, onion rings, potato wedges, fried raviolis, cheddar bites and mini tacos.

Onion Rings
$5.99
Mushroom Caps
$7.49
Cheddar Bites
$5.49

The Plate

Plate
$14.99/+ tax

Your choice of two:
Red/White Hots, Hamburger, Cheeseburger, Chicken Fingers, Sausage Patties

Plus your choice of two:
Macaroni Salad, Baked Beans, Homefries. Topped with Your Choice of Our Famous Meat Sauce, Ketchup, Onions, Etc. and Bread

Dessert

5” Round Otis Spunkmeyer Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.99
Raspberry Dessert Logs
$8.99

4 deep fried logs filled with sweet cream cheese and raspberry filling dusted in powered sugar w/side of chocolate sauce.

Fried Dough (12 pieces)
$5.95

W/cinnamon & sugar and chocolate dipping sauce.

Menu

Family Deal
$49.49/+ tax

16” Large Cheese Pizza w/1 Topping, 24 Buffalo Wings, OR 32 Boneless Wings OR NEW 2lb Chicken Fingers & 2 Liter Pop

Meal Deal
$33.49/+ tax

14” Medium Cheese Pizza w/1 Topping, 12 Buffalo Wings, OR 16 Boneless Wings OR NEW 1lb Chicken Fingers & 2 Liter Pop

Party Deal
$71.99/+ tax

1 Sheet Pizza, Cheese & 1 Topping, 50 Buffalo Wings OR 60 Boneless Wings
OR NEW 4lb Chicken Fingers & 2 Liter Pop

Monday - Tuesday Deal
$36.49/+ tax

16” Large Cheese Pizza w/1 Topping, 12 Buffalo Wings OR 16 Boneless Wings
OR NEW 1lb Chicken Fingers & 2 Liter Pop

Monday Special
$16.99/+ tax

16” Large Cheese w/1 Topping Pizza

Small Special
$19.49/+ tax

1 Small 10” Cheese, + 1 Topping Pizza, 6 Buffalo Wings OR 7 Boneless Wings OR NEW 1/2 lb Chicken Fingers & 1 Liter Pop

Extra Large Special
$54.49/+ tax

1 Huge 20” Cheese Pizza, + 1 Topping, 30 Buffalo Wings OR 36 Boneless Wings OR NEW 3lb Chicken Fingers & 2 Liter Pop

  • Order
  • Jobs